How to Migrate an Audience From One Social Profile to Another

Everything ends eventually – even social profiles. But, good marketing strategy can make pivoting toward something new a little less painful.

So, when one of our clients asked us to close down a couple of old social profiles, we set to work to capture what value we could from the accounts. Here’s how we migrated audiences from one social profile to another.

The Situation

One of our clients had created social profiles for a non-core brand. Over several years, through strategy and engagement, those social profiles had accumulated followers – around 1,300 followers on Facebook, and around 800 on Twitter.

However, over time the non-core brands slowly became less and less relevant to our client’s business focus. As that happened, maintaining the pages became more of a chore than a strategy of visible impact. This is important to note as we’ll talk about this in the reflection of the campaign below.

And so, our client decided the time had come to shut them down. But they didn’t want to send two substantial audiences off into the social media void without migrating some of them to main accounts.

That’s where we came in.

The Migration

Our goal was to capture as many followers as possible from the closing accounts, and migrate them toward our client’s main accounts. This took different forms on Twitter and Facebook, respectively.

Twitter

1. We used a direct message Twitter campaign to migrate followers of the non-core page to the core page.

All followers of the page received a direct message explaining the migration: the impending closure of the page, and the relevancy of our client’s core account to their interest. There was a link in the messages to our client’s official account.

This was all done manually, without the use of a paid, automated messaging program.

2. We created a series of posts to the account, encouraging the migration and reinforcing the details involved.

Posts featured text-based images, quickly reinforcing major details of the migration for high visibility.

Recommended for You

Webcast, October 17th: How to Solve Your Marketing Data Nightmare

3. At account closure, we created a pinned tweet detailing the closure and migration.

The pinned tweet was left on the account for three months after closure.

Facebook

On Facebook, we focused only on posts to the page, with messages updated and reinforced over the month prior to the account closure.

The Results

Results for Core Facebook Page

Over the course of the migration, the core page acquired 8 new likes (an increase of 2.4%). Over the previous period, the page had acquired 0 new likes.

Net Likes on Core Facebook Page

Results for Core Twitter Page

Note that Twitter analytics don’t allow customized date ranges on follower growth, making presenting data in a graph more difficult. However, the follower count of the main profile increased by 57 followers within the week after the direct message campaign was enacted.

The Reaction

Overall, the campaign to migrate as many followers as possible from extraneous social accounts onto our clients official pages demonstrated a few interesting things.

1. Notably, the Twitter efforts were much more effective, almost certainly thanks to the direct message campaign. Additionally, however, organic posts performed more effectively on Twitter.
2. That’s unsurprising, given that Facebook’s algorithms greatly favor paid posts as opposed to organic. On Facebook, organic posts were the only migration method employed.
3. Perhaps most interestingly, though, this campaign could likely have been enhanced with paid promotion on both platforms, which would have enabled a larger reach. That’s especially true on Facebook, where organic reach is at an all time low, but it’s also likely true on Twitter.
4. Lastly, and more reflective on the entire campaign – the accounts were likely”dead” long before this campaign took place. The numbers are not fantastic admittedly. But in reflection on the overall engagement metrics from the channel, we might have skimmed off any live left in the channels to the new more cared for channel. Had they done this in a place where engagement was high, it might have resulted in something else result wise.

The Lesson

Hopefully, this case study is helpful if you find yourself seeking to migrate an audience from one channel to another – these tactics and takeaways will apply directly to you.

Even if you’re not getting ready to migrate a social account, though, perhaps the bigger takeaway is this: you’re always best served by a constantly evolving approach to marketing that’s based on results and data.