At Forrester, we talk a lot about the age of the customer — a 20-year business cycle where empowered customers are shaping industries. Within the media industry, publishers usually have two main types of customers:
- Advertisers that want to buy ad space to reach a publisher’s audience
- Consumers who read/watch/view the publisher’s content
Publishers Have Been Burnt In The Age of The Customer
Historically, publishers have made most of their profit and revenue from selling ads. Some publishers also rake in money from subscriptions or newsstands.
But in the age of the customer, technology has completely changed the way that we consume news, TV shows, movies, music, etc. And it has also changed the way that advertisers buy ad space from publishers.
The result for publishers? Their bottom lines have been squeezed on both the advertiser side and the consumer side. As publishing has gone digital, advertisers can buy ads for a fraction the price compared to print ads. And consumers have largely grown accustomed to accessing content for free. So publishers have been forced to rethink their business models to find cost savings and make decisions on how best to win, serve, and retain customers in this new age.
Now, Publishers Are Prioritizing Consumers Over Advertisers
There is evidence in the earnings statements from premium publishers that they are choosing consumers over advertisers as the path forward. They realize that vying for consumer attention is harder than ever, and if they lose these consumers, then they lose advertisers too — a smaller audience size means fewer impressions for advertisers. Rather than try to appease advertisers, publishers are investing in producing quality content and luring in new subscribers. A few points of evidence from recent earnings calls:
- The New York Times in its Q4 2019 earnings saw both print and digital ad revenue decrease 10% YoY. The publisher said that it “expected to continue generating revenue more from readers than from the advertisers.” The New York Times also recently said it will remove programmatic ads from its mobile app due to ads slowing down its loading time.
- In Meredith’s Q2 2020 earnings, its CEO Thomas Harty explained, “…we are growing consumer related revenues that is reducing our reliance on traditional advertising.” This quote builds on Meredith’s Q1 2020 earnings, where Harty stated, “As we see decreased advertising demand or volume over time, we plan to change the portfolio and look at opportunities to increase our consumer revenue.”
- In Tribune Publishing’s Q3 2019 earnings, CEO Timothy Knight remarked, “We continue to make progress on our stated goals of margin improvement and growing our digital-only subscriber base.”
Where Do Publishers Go Next?
While the evidence suggests that publishers don’t care as much about advertising revenue, they still need it to thrive. I have some questions that I intend to explore this year and would love to hear your take on:
- At what point do consumers begin to reject subscriptions for so many types of content (streaming services, news publishers, etc.)?
- How far do publishers go in prioritizing the consumer over the advertiser?
- What backlash could this have with advertisers?
I would love to hear your thoughts — feel free to shoot me a note on LinkedIn or email me directly ([email protected]).